Charity is better than Umrah: Depending on Circumstances

 Praise be to Allah.

Giving charity at a time of need and extreme hunger is of greater virtue than doing a voluntary ‘umrah. 

This is because the benefit of ‘umrah is limited to the one who does it, whereas the benefit of giving charity to the needy and the hungry goes beyond the individual, and that of which the benefit spreads further is of greater virtue than that of which the benefit is limited.

Reference: Islamqa.info/en